Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sara Robinson's avatar

We keep coming back to the idea that nobody -- then or now -- denigrates the folks who were able to escape Europe in the late 1930s as having abandoned their nations, or as somehow having failed.

What they were were the lucky ones who had the sense and the means to see what was coming, and get out ahead of it. You cannot fault them for their wisdom or their foresight. There is no shame in following their example, because they're the ones whose lives and legacies survived.

I do feel a bit like I bailed. I'm a Mayflower descendant, a six-times-over DAR candidate, the great-great-granddaughter of a Union general. For all those generations, my ancestors stuck by America through whatever came, and fought whatever battles needed fighting. I absolutely feel like I'm failing to uphold an essential family tradition.

But my husband's great-grandparents left Kiev and Odessa on the eve of WWI. And they never looked back. They arrived in the US in 1913 with nothing. 20 years later, they owned a chain of grocery stores that spanned Los Angeles. So I'm taking my cues from him -- and them.

In turbulent eras like this one, there's more than one way to win. Like my husband's ancestors, we're choosing the one that will keep our family and our fortune more or less intact and moving forward into a better future. As legacies go, I'll take it.

Expand full comment
Lori's avatar

There's a tremendous amount of privilege that you, and others who can use this template, have to be able to utilize this. I'm glad for those who have such a wide range of options to be able to have multiple pathways. I appreciate your articulating how to make a plan along with fallbacks. I just needed to state a few things that people may not even think about due to their level of privilege.

Visa options are limited for those who are retired unless you have a lot of financial wealth; there are some countries that welcome retirees, but in a warming world, the choices narrow quickly. For those whose ancestors are from the global majority, getting a visa by descent rules out EU countries and many countries that have some kind of democratic government. For those who are disabled or have chronic health issues, the options for countries that are accessible or accessible-friendly become even smaller. The options for redundancy or fallback are few to none. The systemic injustices are made starkly visible, just like looking at a budget to see what is truly important by what is funded, it becomes clear who is valued by who is encouraged to live there vs who is not. I'm still exploring, and would certainly appreciate suggestions... and I am acutely aware that there will be many who will not even have choices.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts